World Religions - PHIL105

Scholarly Articles

Scholarly articles are published in peer-reviewed academic journals. Sometimes they are referred to as peer-reviewed articles. The library databases may also tell you a source is from an academic journal. Those options are usually scholarly articles, but ask a librarian or your professor if you aren't sure! One example of something published in an academic journal that is not a scholarly article is a book review.

These articles share research findings from a very specific research question, so the content is very narrow in scope. You will have to use multiple scholarly articles to support a multi-faceted research paper like the one you are writing for this class.

What is the difference between scholarly and popular articles?

To find scholarly journal articles for your research paper, you need to know some features that distinguish scholarly articles from news, magazine, and general webpage articles. These differences exist whether you find the articles through an internet search or a library database.

Comparison of characteristics of scholarly and popular articles

What to Know	Scholarly Journal Articles	Popular Articles (news, magazines, webpages)
Who writes them?	Experts in a field Researchers Scholars or Professors	Reporters or journalists Staff writers Free-lance writers
Who reads them?	Researchers and Experts Scholars (including students) People with knowledge of the topic	General public People who do not have in-depth knowledge of the topic
What do they look like?	"Serious" looking - mostly text, some charts, graphs, or tables Fewer advertisements or illustrations Generally longer articles Articles online or in databases are often in PDF format to appear similar to a print journal See how scholarly articles are organized	Glossy, color photographs Commercial advertisements Easy-to-read or eye-catching layout Articles online often have hyperlinks to other relevant articles throughout the text
What are they about?	Original research studies or experiments In-depth analysis of a specific topic or theory Critical analysis (criticism)	Entertainment and popular culture Current events and news Opinion pieces or articles with an emotional slant
Who reviews them?	Peer reviewers - an editorial board of experts in the discipline	Staff editors and publishers
What are they used for?	Finding current research about a specific aspect of your topic Learning what the experts say about your topic and using it to support your thesis	Broad overviews of current topics Information about popular culture Introduction to an unfamiliar topic
What are some examples?

Using scholarly articles

Now that you know how scholarly articles differ from sources you are more familiar with, we will look at how you use them. Since these articles are written for an academic audience that already has some knowledge of the topic, they can be complex and packed full of technical information!

Reading scholarly articles

Believe it or not, you are not expected to read a scholarly article straight through from beginning to end! In fact, you will better understand its contents if you take a different approach, and read it slightly out of order:

1. Title. With scholarly sources, titles are straightforward and describe what the article is about. Titles often include relevant key words.

2. The Abstract is a summary of the author(s)'s research findings and tells what to expect when you read the full article. It is often a good idea to read the abstract first, in order to determine if you should even bother reading the whole article.

3. Discussion and Conclusion. Read these after the Abstract (even though they come at the end of the article). These sections can help you see if this article will meet your research needs. If you don’t think that it will, set it aside.

4. Introduction. The introduction is meatier than the Abstract. Here you see where the author(s) enter the conversation on this topic. That is to say, what related research has come before, and how do they hope to advance the discussion with their current research?

5. The Methods section explains how the study worked. Again, reading this section, you can think critically about the work that the authors have done, and decide whether it applies to your own research question. In this section, you often learn who and how many participated in the study and what they were asked to do. In the social sciences, sub-sections might include Materials and Procedure.

6. In the Results section (can also be called Data), there can be a lot of numbers and tables. If you are not a whiz at statistics, this can be a challenging section to understand. Since the Discussion and Conclusion sections provide the necessary summary of these results, it's okay to skim over this section.

7. The References page is often the most important. It might also be called Works Cited or Bibliography. This section comprises the author(s)’s sources. Always be sure to scroll through them. Good research usually cites many different kinds of sources (books, journal articles, etc.). Train yourself to notice the differences between source types in your field’s citation style. As you read the References page, be sure to look for sources that look like they will help you to answer your own research question. It’s considered best practices – and a real time-saver—to do so.

Reading Scholarly Articles list modified from the original Research Toolkit by Wendy Hayden and Stephanie Margolin, and is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.